Have you ever tried to log in to a site or complete a purchase and then gotten asked, “Are you human? Prove it!” Then you find yourself selecting buses, motorcycles, streetlights, etc. Pretty simple, right? Well, now it’s simple for certain bots too. That’s why it’s important to know the new methods out there that don’t just automate the sorting of humans vs. bots, but also enhance security to keep you and your site better protected.
reCAPTCHA: What is it, and why should you care?
reCAPTCHA v2 is a tool Google developed to fight bots that were spamming logins or trying to get access where you would want only human interaction. That gave birth to those tile puzzles that confirm you’re human, or a simple checkbox. It made things easy because it became a binary decision: human or bot. This was OK for a time, but it became cumbersome, and even more difficult on mobile devices.
Then came reCAPTCHA v3, which improved this by removing the puzzles and making the enforcement invisible, reducing friction and changing the way it determined if you were human or not. Now it gave you a score: if you scored 1.0, you were likely a human, and if you scored 0.0, you were likely a bot.
You could score in between, so then what happens? Well, that would be up to you to determine. You can decide if you want to let in only 1.0s or lower the threshold to 0.5 to ensure you don’t miss any human interactions that have been incorrectly scored.
This does require some additional configuration and analysis of your traffic. You also only get 10,000 free assessments per month. After that, expect to pay Google a flat $8 per month for up to 100,000 assessments, plus $1 per 1,000 after that. Also, recently there have been some privacy concerns because it saves cookies or history from your account for other reCAPTCHA sites.
Now, are these the only two options? Nope. I present to you Cloudflare Turnstile.
Does Turnstile turn the tables?
Not quite, but it does improve on some things reCAPTCHA misses. First off, it’s FREE! Currently, there is no limit to how many assessments Turnstile does.
Cloudflare (a major DNS and security provider used across the internet) developed Turnstile as an alternative to reCAPTCHA. Instead of asking for a checkbox confirmation or interactive challenges, it runs invisible challenges in your browser and bases its analysis on your behavior heuristics.
In other words, it determines if you’re human by what you do and how you do it in your browser. Bots don’t waste time and don’t click unnecessarily, but we do sometimes.
Now, Cloudflare has also added Turnstile Spin, a setup tool that lets AI coding agents install Turnstile on your site and can even help migrate you from other CAPTCHA providers. Also, no cookies, so it won’t track your account information and use it for other assessments on other sites using Turnstile.
The downside? Turnstile is new. Released in 2022, it doesn’t have the historic knowledge Google reCAPTCHA has acquired during its years of analysis. Also, this will require some additional configuration on your site to get it to work properly, just like reCAPTCHA would.
So, which do I choose?
Excellent question, and the answer is simple. It depends. What are you currently using?
Google has moved all reCAPTCHA versions into Google Cloud and now caps free use at 10,000 assessments a month, so you may be in a place to upgrade to reCAPTCHA v3, or you can use Cloudflare Turnstile. After analyzing your needs, you may choose either depending on your preferences.
Not sure which you are using or whether you need to upgrade? Let us help. Reach out to CMHWorks, and after a quick discussion, we can make this an easy decision for you, because our goal, as always, is: Making Technology easy for YOU and YOUR business.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between reCAPTCHA and Cloudflare Turnstile?
Both tools help websites tell humans apart from bots. reCAPTCHA is made by Google and either shows a puzzle or checkbox (v2) or assigns an invisible score (v3). Turnstile is made by Cloudflare and runs invisible challenges in your browser, with no puzzles and no tracking cookies.
Is Google reCAPTCHA still free?
Partly. reCAPTCHA is free for up to 10,000 assessments a month. After that, Google charges a flat $8 per month for up to 100,000 assessments, plus $1 per 1,000 assessments beyond that.
Is Cloudflare Turnstile free?
Yes. Turnstile is free, and there is currently no limit on how many assessments it runs.
Is Google discontinuing reCAPTCHA v2?
Not exactly. Google has moved all reCAPTCHA versions into Google Cloud, and existing v2 keys still work. The bigger change is the new 10,000 free assessments a month cap, so it is a good time to review whether v2, v3, or Turnstile is the right fit.
What is the difference between reCAPTCHA v2 and v3?
reCAPTCHA v2 asks users to click a checkbox or solve an image puzzle. reCAPTCHA v3 runs invisibly in the background and gives each visitor a score from 0.0 (likely a bot) to 1.0 (likely a human), and you decide where to set the cutoff.
Does switching from reCAPTCHA to Turnstile require changes to my website?
Yes. Like reCAPTCHA, Turnstile needs some configuration on your site to work properly. CMHWorks can handle the setup and make sure your forms and logins keep working smoothly.
How do I know which CAPTCHA my website uses?
If you are not sure what is protecting your forms and logins, reach out to CMHWorks. We can check your site, explain your options, and help you make the switch if it makes sense for your business.
Was this article helpful?
Thanks for your feedback.
Have a question about this topic?